Burt Reynolds's Near-Miss with "Crocodile Dundee": A Hollywood What-If
Burt Reynolds, the iconic Hollywood star known for his rugged charm and box-office successes, almost starred in one of the most surprising cinematic hits of the 80s: Crocodile Dundee. While Paul Hogan ultimately cemented the role of Mick Dundee into cinematic history, the journey to finding the perfect leading man was a fascinating one, and Burt Reynolds's near-participation adds a compelling layer to the film's legacy.
The Casting Process: A Search for "Aussie"
Casting Crocodile Dundee presented a unique challenge. Producers needed an actor who could convincingly portray a rugged, charismatic Australian outback man, yet also possess the charm to win over American audiences. This wasn't just about acting ability; it was about finding the right physicality and embodying a specific persona. Paul Hogan, initially conceived as a supporting character, eventually landed the lead role, partly due to his undeniable on-screen presence. But before Hogan’s star rose, other actors were considered, including the legendary Burt Reynolds.
Why Burt Reynolds? The Appeal of a Hollywood Heavyweight
Reynolds, at the peak of his career in the 1980s, was a highly sought-after actor. His action-comedy roles, often showcasing his charisma and physical prowess, made him a natural fit for a film like Crocodile Dundee. The film’s producers likely saw in Reynolds the potential to draw a large audience, capitalizing on his established fanbase and star power. His rough-around-the-edges persona, honed through years of playing lovable rogues, would have lent itself well to the character of Mick Dundee.
The Missed Opportunity: What Could Have Been
Imagining Burt Reynolds as Mick Dundee is a fascinating exercise. His portrayal would undoubtedly have been different from Hogan's. While Hogan brought a uniquely Australian, down-to-earth quality to the role, Reynolds would have likely brought a more polished, Hollywood-style charisma. The film's humor and pacing might have shifted, potentially leaning more toward Reynolds's established comedic style. This doesn't necessarily mean a worse film, just a significantly different one. The chemistry between Reynolds and Linda Kozlowski, who played Sue Charlton, would have been another significant variable.
The Legacy of "What Ifs" in Hollywood
The casting of Crocodile Dundee highlights the often-unpredictable nature of Hollywood. While Reynolds's involvement might have yielded a successful film, it's ultimately Hogan's performance that solidified the film's enduring legacy. The "what if" scenarios surrounding casting choices are a common theme in Hollywood history, reminding us that even the smallest decisions can significantly impact a film's reception and lasting impact. The success of Crocodile Dundee with Paul Hogan underscores the importance of finding the right actor for the right role, even if that means defying initial expectations.
Conclusion: A Hollywood Tale of Two Stars
Burt Reynolds’ near-casting in Crocodile Dundee remains a compelling "what if" in Hollywood history. It showcases the dynamic and often unpredictable nature of the film industry's casting process. While we'll never truly know what a Reynolds-led Crocodile Dundee would have looked like, the mere possibility serves as a fascinating testament to the film’s enduring appeal and the power of casting choices in shaping cinematic legacy. The story ultimately underlines that sometimes, the unexpected choice leads to iconic success.